Posts Tagged Stephen M. Pollan
Barbaric Book Review: Die Broke by Stephen M. Pollan, Part 2
Posted by enrique s in Book & Product Reviews, Frugality, Money on April 21st, 2009
This is Part 2 of my review of Die Broke. You can read Part 1 by following this link: Barbaric Book Review: Die Broke by Stephen M. Pollan
The authors feel that there are three things that will keep you trapped: an unwillingness to change, and your ATM and credit cards. These cards represent instant gratification, making it too easy to spend your money. In order to achieve the goals laid out in the book, you should make spending difficult and uncomfortable.
The argument is that ATM and credit cards take the pain out of spending. You don’t focus on the amount spent if you’re not counting out the cash. Online banking and automatic payments distance you even more from bill paying, and you may be charged for the convenience.
The authors offer a few suggestions for Saving and Spending in the Twenty-First Century:
- Melt Your Plastic - Remove all credit cards from your wallet, and replace them with a charge card for emergencies. Consolidate your debt on a low interest credit card, and put the card away.
- Bank with People - Remove the ATM card from your wallet also, and go to the bank once a week for cash. Withdraw the cash by writing yourself a check. Don’t spend any more than you’ve withdrawn.
- Practice Cognitive Spending - Keep track of where every dollar is spent on an index card, then categorize your expenses each week. This will get you to think about how you spend your money.
- Buy Your Second Home First - The real estate boom was an anomaly traceable to the baby boom generation driving up the prices for a limited number of homes. Don’t practice serial home ownership, but save for your dream home.
- Avoid “Everest” Buying - Don’t buy something “because it’s there.” Buy things only when you need them, not when you want them.
- Ignore the New - Don’t buy the latest gadget, but wait forsomething that answers a true need.
- Repair Before You Replace - Retailers profit more on new things than repairing old things, so focus on repairing what you have.
- Pay Yourself First - Put away what you can in your 401K, and do it automatically.
My Take:
- For people that have no self-control, this is the best advice. However, if you’re responsible, you can use credit cards to your advantage, such as rewards or zero-interest arbitrage, provided you pay off the balance each month.
- I’m disciplined enough that I don’t abuse my ATM card. I stick to my weekly budget. I rarely go to the bank.
- I track most large expenses, but our walking-around money doesn’t get analyzed. As long as we stay under our weekly allowance I’m happy.
- Well, we’re living in our first home, and probably will for the near future. We bought the home in part for the tax advantages, and have added on to it over time, paying cash for the improvements. We’ve also paid off our mortgage.
- I use a cooling-off period to counteract impulse buys. Can’t argue with that one.
- Or that one, either.
- I repair rather than replace if it makes sense. I’m not upgrading an old computer if I can buy a new one for the same price as the repair.
- We do this. The key is to automate it. Pretend you didn’t get that raise, and put that away, too.
In Part 3 of my review of Die Broke, we’ll examine the third step, called Don’t Retire.
Follow me on Twitter: CorpBarbarian
|
|
|
|
|
![]() |
Related Posts -
Getting Rich in America Book Review and Summary, Part 2 This is Part 2 of my review and chapter summary of Getting Rich in America: 8 Simple Rules for Building a Fortune and a Satisfying Life by Dwight R. Lee and Richard B. McKenzie. You can read Part 1 of this review by clicking the following link: Getting Rich in...... -
Pay Off Debt or Save Money? Photo by db*photography A recent Yahoo! Finance article weighed the benefits of paying off debt versus putting your money into savings. You can read the original article by clicking on the following link: Should You Pay Debt Before Saving? Clearly, there is no one-size-fits-all answer to the question. The...... -
Americans Who Permanently Cut Their Spending SqueakyMarmot Many people have adopted a cash-only lifestyle in response to one financial catastrophe or another. It could be tied to a job loss that shuts off the cash flow, forcing people to take a hard look at their outstanding debts. But even though they may have put their......
Related Websites -
6 Steps to Get Back on the Right Financial Track Millions of Americans have found out this year that they are in dire financial straits and this came as a shock to most. Whether it’s a new variable rate on a mortgage, higher gas prices or just the higher cost of living, many of us are not as financially secure...... -
Why do I still have to carry cash? Photo by: Andrew Ciscel I'm trying really hard to stop using cash. But it seems no matter how hard I try, I run into some situation that requires cash. Some weeks back, we decided to take a ride on the new light rail system our city recently built. I...... -
Saving Money with Your Credit Cards pt 1 When it comes to personal budgeting, we tend to try to think of ways that we can cut corners while cutting down on any frivolous expenses in our lives. What many people are not apparently aware of however is that you can actually make use of credit cards to help......
Barbaric Book Review: Die Broke by Stephen M. Pollan, Part 1
Posted by enrique s in Book & Product Reviews, Career, Frugality, Money on April 20th, 2009
In Die Broke, Stephen M. Pollan and Mark Levine propose “a radical, four-part financial plan to restore your confidence, increase your net worth, and afford you the lifestyle of your dreams.” Hey, sign me up! The book, first published in 1997, attempts to poke holes in conventional financial and estate planning. Though published over ten years ago, the material seems rather timely, namely the authors’ assumption that real estate values will be stagnant, and excessive borrowing will lead to financial ruin. Let’s take a look at the four-part plan. We’ll start with the first step, called Quit Today.
Step One: Quit Today
The first step in the Die Broke philosophy is to realize that job security is dead. The authors want us to give up hope of following the outdated Career Ethic that created the loyal, organization man of our parents’ time. We shouldn’t be defined by our jobs, or seek self-fulfillment from our careers. We should separate ourselves from our jobs, to pay more attention to our own bottom lines as we do to our company’s. A job should be used to generate the money necessary for you to pursue your financial goals, and nothing more. The authors call this the Mercantile Ethic, and lay out these principles:
- It’s Just a Job - Forget about a holistic work life, and concentrate on actually having a life.
- Jump Ship - Quit in your head, as the only way to increase job satisfaction and/or income is to get another job. The more job hopping that you do, the more likely you’ll increase income. Always look for a new job.
- Short Term is the Only Term - Long-term benefits like pensions are worthless if you’re fired before becoming fully vested. Focus instead on short-term benefits that will improve your quality of life, such as health insurance, day care, parental leave, telecommuting, flex-time, and even health club memberships.
- Lateral is Better than Vertical - It’s better to take a lateral move that expands your skills than it is to take a position with greater responsibility. There’s probably no increase in pay, just the chance to be a scapegoat. Added skills make it easier to jump ship.
- Will This Be on the Test? - Learn exactly what’s expected of you and do it the best you can. Do your job well, then go home.
- Just Do It - Pay no attention to company politics. Who gets credit doesn’t matter.
- There Are No Dues - There’s no point in paying your dues, as jobs must make economic sense from day one.
- Show Me the Money - The only reward that matters is what you are paid. Everything other than money can come from the rest of your life. Your job is the only part of your life that will bring you money, so you need to maximize that.
My Take:
- Wow, and here I was following Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs all these years. I’ve always looked for something else besides money from my job, whether it’s friendship, company softball games, golf outings, respect, etc.
- I tend to only look for a new job when I feel that I’ve stopped learning. I treat my job as a kind of paid schooling. Why leave if class isn’t over yet?
- I don’t know about you, but if I have to put in an extra year to become vested in a pension, I’m doing my best to try to stick around.
- I agree with this one, why take a promotion on a promise of greater income, when the company would have to hire someone from outside at the going rate.
- You should always know what your job responsibilities are, and they should be defined by your boss.
- It’s hard to ignore company politics if they affect you directly.
- I think you have to pay some dues when you join a new company. It’s just part of learning the job, and earning people’s respect.
- I guess the bottom line is the bottom line, though I do get more out of my job than just a paycheck.
We’ll take a look at Step 2, Pay Cash, in Part 2 of the Die Broke review.
Follow me on Twitter: CorpBarbarian
Print This Post
|
|
|
|
|
![]() |
Related Posts -
Barbaric Book Review: Die Broke by Stephen M. Pollan, Part 4 This is Part 4 of my review of Die Broke. You can read the first three parts of this series by clicking on the following links: Die Broke, Part 1 - Quit Today Die Broke, Part 2 - Pay Cash Die Broke, Part 3 - Don't Retire Step 4: Die...... -
Corporate Barbarian Links: Graduation Party Edition bionicteaching We threw a graduation party for my son, two weeks prior to his real graduation. We did it early because we wanted our relatives to attend, and didn't want to interfere with everyone's summer vacation plans. It was great to see family and friends that I usually only...... -
Getting the Most Out of Your Per Diem Photo by kainet I was on a business trip recently with other members of my "team". When the subject of dinner came up, one of the members, who will remain nameless, suggested the Golden Arches. That's right, McDonalds. He wanted to try to make money on the trip, and......
Related Websites -
Seven Secrets to Financial Independence One could probably build a small library for the books written on the subject of financial independence. It's a subject many of us like to fantasize about, but few of us will see materialize in our lifetimes. Why? Mostly because we allow competing priorities, egos and financial peer pressure dictate...... -
Dividend Investing Supplements Passive Income I've written before about the various passive income streams available, but up until now I have largely ignored the concept of dividend investing. That was until the recession caused interest rates to drop to levels that don't even keep pace with inflation. As I searched for higher yields, I was...... -
Roundup for week of 4 August 2007: A&W Root Beer Edition Here are some great articles from blogs I check out:Blueprint for Financial Prosperity doesn't trust anyone either.Consumerism Commentary would take this penny for his thoughts.Five Cent Nickel wonders if online banking has come of age.Free Money Finance speaks on Rule 240.All Financial Matters discussed the eminently quotable Ben Stein.The Simple......









