Posts Tagged Great Expectations

Photo by Svadilfari

I had two meetings yesterday.  One was a status meeting with a group of engineers, and the other was a meeting with a proposal manager.  What struck me was the difference in how people behaved during each of the meetings.

…it was the spring of hope…

The first meeting, with the engineers, was a weekly status meeting on a development program.  It was held in a conference room in the engineering area of my building.  The conference room was a bare-bones affair, with a nondescript table and chairs, and no windows.  The walls were covered with project schedules, and every available inch of counter space held a prototype of some unknown product.  This was where work got done.  It was cramped, to be generous, and I kept hitting elbows with the lefty seated to my right.

…it was the winter of despair…

The second meeting, with the proposal manager, was held in a conference room that was brightly lit from a south-facing window.  This room was located in what is commonly referred to as “mahogany row”, the executive area of the building.  The only reason you ever get called down there is to take your lumps in front of the VP for some screw up.  It’s the place where angels fear to tread.  But I digress.  This cavernous conference room had a shiny cherry wood table with matching chair rail, and plush leather chairs that I could have taken a nap in.  The matching cherry sidebar held two trays of pastries.  First class, all the way.

Take nothing on its looks; take everything on evidence. There’s no better rule. - Charles Dickens, Great Expectations

Guess which meeting was more productive?  While the engineers in the first meeting resembled a frat party, the proposal meeting took on the ambiance of a court martial.  My great expectations were dashed.  The first meeting, in the crappier conference room, offered a forum for everyone to speak freely.  Problems were addressed, without judgments being passed for minor errors.  There was a positive vibe, an exuberance that though they had experienced some setbacks, they could ultimately make the design work.  The second meeting had all of the exuberance of a chess match.  Things were not going well for this proposal, and time was running out.  I had the sense that everyone was sharpening their knives, ready to pounce on the person who dared to utter a discouraging word.  After an hour and change, not much was accomplished.

My point?  It doesn’t take fancy conference rooms and ultra-modern equipment to get things accomplished; what matters most is the mix of people involved.  Surround yourself with the wrong crew, and misery awaits.  Find the right people, and you can accomplish anything.  To paraphrase Dickens, it will be a far, far better thing that you do for your career, than you have ever done.

I have another proposal meeting this afternoon.  I hope they still have pastries.

Follow me on Twitter: CorpBarbarian

• September 2009 Recap Photo by LeSmou Imperator September was a good month, if you're a New York sports fan.  The Bombers clinched another division title, and the Giants are undefeated.  Now, if A.J. Burnett can get himself straightened out, and the Giants don't suffer any more injuries, October should be even better!......
• For the Love of God, Don't Just Read the PowerPoint Charts! danorth1 An Invitation to a Meeting I received an email at work that invited me to attend an overview on a new procedure.  Attached to the email was a copy of the PowerPoint file that would accompany the presentation.  Nice touch, thought I.  I can skim through it beforehand,......
• My First 100 Days Theresa Thompson Yesterday was Day 100 of this blog.  Since people like to examine the first 100 days of new regimes, I figured that I'd throw out some statistics, just in case you were curious.  I know I was curious, and amazed.  Amazed that anyone would read my stuff. ......

• Meeting That Special Someone A few weeks ago I asked some of my friends at Romance Divas where they met their partners. The answers ranged from online dating sites to college to in the workplace. It was a fun conversation, bringing happy memories for many of us. The truth is that it’s not......
• Audio Conferencing - Perfect Way Of Distant Communication Audio Conferencing is one among the few others popular types of modern communication tools used in disposing distant communication problems. Breaking all the distance, this way of communication enables you to talk to several people sitting in different geographical locations at the same time. Unlike earlier when Audio Conferencing was......
• Don't Lose Your Virtual Meeting Attendees There are right ways and wrong ways to run a meeting that has virtual participants and yesterday I had the privilege of seeing it done right! Yesterday I went to an all-day face-to-face meeting with a team in my organization. There were about 15 people attending in person and 3......