jaqian

A recent Wall Street Journal article revealed that our country’s savings rate may be lower than the accepted 6.9%.  A person who has studied the savings rate for years has adjusted for the stimulus package, and has arrived at a much lower number:

Charles Biderman of TrimTabs Investment Research, an economic-analysis firm in Sausalito, Calif., has studied the saving rate for years. He adjusted for one-time boosts from the stimulus package and used daily income-tax reports from the U.S. Treasury to take the latest job losses into account. By this revised estimate, the saving rate may actually be running as low as 0.9%.

Yikes!  I guess we haven’t learned our lesson.  Saving may feel impossible for many people.  But fear not, fellow non-saver.  Some bright guy at Harvard may have come up with a plan:

But psychologists have long known that people tend to overestimate the odds of rare events. Applying that behavioral insight, finance professor Peter Tufano of Harvard Business School has devised a clever program called “Save to Win.” Launched earlier this year for members of eight credit unions in Michigan, it is a cross between a certificate of deposit and a raffle ticket. Members who put $25 or more into a Save to Win one-year CD are entered into a monthly “savings raffle” for prizes up to $400, plus one annual drawing for a $100,000 jackpot. Only Michigan residents are eligible to participate.

This unusual CD is federally guaranteed by the National Credit Union Administration and pays between 1% and 1.5% annual interest, a bit lower than conventional rates. In 25 weeks, the program has attracted about $3.1 million in new deposits, often from people who have never been able to set money aside.

So, let me get this straight.  People are investing more in a lower-rate CD than a conventional one, because they have a chance to win a  prize in a raffle?  Is this the movie Idiocracy come to life?  I could go on about the opportunity cost of the lower interest earned, and the remote odds of winning the drawing, but you probably already know that.  If you’re in dire financial straits, you should sock away as much as you can, in order to take advantage of the magic of compound interest.  I don’t see how this program is doing the less fortunate any favors.  If people pass on buying lottery tickets in order to buy the CD, then I can see it as the lesser of two evils.

Maybe they should offer financial education books as one of the prizes.

• Deming's 14 Points Back when I was working towards my MBA, I had a professor that was very passionate.  Let's call him Nick.  One night, Nick polled the class, asking us who we thought was the epitome of a great leader, a person whose policies allowed for everyone to win.  When one......
• Barbaric Book Review: The Wealthy Barber The Wealthy Barber by David Chilton was first published in 1991.  It's a basic financial guide, told in a narrative style, about three young people who seek financial advice from the town barber.  Yes, you read that correctly, a barber. The story follows a young teacher as he learns, along......
• Barbaric Links: Debt Edition I read a lot of good posts this week regarding debt.  Here are some of my favorite posts on this topic: Kevin at No Debt Plan shares his frustrating lunch encounter; Credit Card Watch prepares to save money with 0% APR credit cards; FiveCentNickel hears ironic debt advice on his......

• Weekend Personal Finance Review Here are some thoughts I had while watching the Red Sox extend their lead over the Yankees to 10.5 games yesterday. I won't feel comfortable until that's at least 25 games. Earlier this week Money, Matter, and More Musings asked What Is The Worth Of *Net Worth* If It Is......
• Great Debates: Retirement Account Redux Welcome back fight fans, to the first grudge match in Great Debate history.  Yes, although we already fought this issue out a while back, it's come up quite a bit in the media lately, and with 2010 being the year that anyone can convert their traditional account into a Roth......
• The Easiest Way To Save Money Ever! Many people have a hard time saving money because there are so many things that they want to spend their money on.  There are bills to pay and food to buy, clothing to replace and gas to purchase, and that doesn't even begin to get into all of the optional......