Photo by db*photography

A recent Yahoo! Finance article weighed the benefits of paying off debt versus putting your money into savings.  You can read the original article by clicking on the following link:

Should You Pay Debt Before Saving?

Clearly, there is no one-size-fits-all answer to the question.  The logical approach favors paying off high-interest debt before putting money in savings.  After all, the difference in interest rates makes this approach a no-brainer.  Why tie up money for 1.25% in a savings account when you could pay off a credit card with a 16% interest rate?

Donna Fox, author of the book “From Credit Repair to Credit Millionaire,” says low interest rates on savings accounts make paying off debt first a better choice right now.

“People get into trouble with debt and finance when they start letting emotions vote on their outcome,” says Fox. “So they feel better if they have a cushion in their savings account, even though for most people it’s not the financial savvy thing to do.”

She cites the example of someone who has $10,000 in savings (earning 2 percent) and $10,000 in credit card debt (at a rate of 9 percent). Anyone pleased with this situation is misguided, Fox says.

“This is like investing your $10,000 in an investment you know will lose 7 percent a year … and being happy about it,” she says.

Sure, this makes sense, from a strictly logical approach.  You could look at one extreme, where you’d apply all of your extra money toward your outstanding debt, and put nothing in the bank.  But would you really feel secure having nothing in your savings account, even though you’re paying down your debt at a higher rate?  True, the debt may disappear faster, but you would have the uneasiness of having nothing in your savings.  What would you do when an emergency happens, and you have no emergency fund?

The other extreme has you paying the minimum payment on all of your debts, and dumping the rest into savings.  Although you’d have enough cash to cover emergencies, it would make paying off the debt a lifelong endeavor.  Clearly a compromise can be struck that doesn’t optimize either side, but creates a proper balance.

Having a stash of emergency cash is more important in today’s economic times of tight credit, says Sarah Place, president and CEO of Place Trade Financial, a full-service, discount brokerage firm based in Raleigh, N.C.

She suggests socking away six to 12 months of easily accessible cash to cover any unexpected expenses. Access to such money is especially important today, when many people have found their home equity line of credit has been reduced — or even canceled.

Place acknowledges that it’s difficult to tell people to save “in an environment where they are earning a fraction of a percent of interest on their savings” while being charged “usurious loan shark rates of over 30 percent on their credit cards.”

Only you can determine the proper size of your emergency fund.  The shakiness of your job will be a factor in the number of months of expenses that you can cover.  An interesting piece of advice was given regarding 401(k) contributions:

Michael Rubin, president of Portsmouth, N.H.-based Total Candor, a provider of financial education, advocates paying down debt before saving. However, he cites exceptions to the rule. In particular, he urges a “save first” approach in situations where a person’s employer matches contributions to the company retirement plan.

“The guarantee provided by a matching program is even more valuable than repaying credit card debt, so one should always maximize the match first,” says Rubin, who is author of the book “Beyond Paycheck to Paycheck: A Conversation About Income, Wealth, and the Steps in Between.”

Or, you could follow Dave Ramsey’s Baby Steps, which have helped many people get their finances under control:

1. $1,000 to start an Emergency Fund
2. Pay off all debt using the Debt Snowball
3. Three to six months of expenses in savings
4. Invest 15 percent of household income into Roth IRAs and pre-tax retirement
5. College funding for children
6. Pay off home early
7. Build wealth and give!  Invest in mutual funds and real estate

The strategy that I used was a balance.  I funded my 401(k) first, and threw the remaining funds at my credit card debt each month.  When that was paid off, I started on the mortgage.  Once that was paid off, I did a little dance of joy, and started saving in earnest.

Find which strategy fits your goals the best, and follow that one.  Don’t be afraid to change it up as you go along.  This isn’t a science, it’s an art.

Did you like this article?  Why not subscribe?

• Barbaric Links: Debt Edition I read a lot of good posts this week regarding debt.  Here are some of my favorite posts on this topic: Kevin at No Debt Plan shares his frustrating lunch encounter; Credit Card Watch prepares to save money with 0% APR credit cards; FiveCentNickel hears ironic debt advice on his......
• Barbaric Book Review: The Wealthy Barber The Wealthy Barber by David Chilton was first published in 1991.  It's a basic financial guide, told in a narrative style, about three young people who seek financial advice from the town barber.  Yes, you read that correctly, a barber. The story follows a young teacher as he learns, along......
• Corporate Barbarian: The Pool is Open Edition jurvetson We opened up the swimming pool this past weekend, so summer should be right around the corner.  All we need now is for the weather to cooperate.  It feels more like April than June.  I spent a couple days scrubbing the winter cover and water bags, and yesterday......

• Saving for a Rainy Day Having a few easy and down to earth concepts and ideas for spending less, cutting expenses and socking money away is a good way to start putting together a rainy day fund. This freed up money can be applied to your emergency fund so that you can weather any financial......
• 5 Effective Tactics For Dealing With Debt It is estimated that 70% of the population are carrying a crippling amount of debt and the amount of debt held by citizens has increased to record levels.  Many people are having these financial troubles and their debts continue to increase as they find themselves spending more than they make......
• How to Avoid Ever Having To Go Into Debt When people go out to buy a new car, major appliance, or other expensive purchase, more often than not they use the store's financing options or throw the purchase on their credit card to pay for their purchases. It's very rare that people pay cash for such purchases now of......