Paul O’Neill hit 21 homers.  Tiki Barber rushed for over 1,600 yards.  Jim Brown scored 17 touchdowns in his last year.  These athletes walked away while they were still at the top of their games.  But this week we saw another example of a person taking one curtain call too many: Brett Favre.

They hung on too long

In his final year, Willie Mays was a shell of the great ballplayer that he once was.  Mickey Mantle was on the decline for several years when he finally retired.  In order to squeeze another year out of his career, Johnny Bench embarrassed himself at third base.  Just this year, Jason Giambi tried to find the old magic back where he started, and put up abysmal numbers.  As the old saying goes, you’ve got to know when to walk away.

Old soldiers never die…

Which brings me to Brett Favre.  I’m a Giants fan, so I have no axe to grind with him leaving the Jets.  In fact, his lousy performance in his last playoff game helped the Giants get to the Super Bowl.  I’m just disappointed that he agreed to play for the Vikings.  I’m sure there are several old #4 jerseys being burned as we speak in Cheesehead Nation, and I can’t blame them for their outrage.  It would be the same for me as if Derek Jeter signed with the Red Sox.  But what gets me is, he thinks he’s still got it.  If you followed the second half of the last football season, you know that’s not the case.

…they just fade away

I see this happen at work.  A notice will go up for a retirement party for so-and-so.  About a month later, I’ll see the retiree in the hallway.  He’s back on the job, and out of his wife’s hair.  The problem is, he’s past his prime.  Maybe well past his prime.  Over the hill.  He doesn’t have the chops anymore.  He may think that he does, but he’s only fooling himself.

Roadblock to progress

Or the case of a guy who was waiting for a severance package, a “golden handshake” that will finally push him out the door.  The problem with this guy was that he was in limbo.  His power had been taken away, given to a younger successor.  But his presence was a hindrance to his successor, who felt the need to defer to the old lion.  People went around the successor’s back to get approval from the old lion.  It undermined the successor’s authority.

Cut the rope

The mere presence of these guys causes a problem for the company:  it can’t move forward.  In order to move on in a new direction, the company needs to cut its ties to these guys.  That’s what the Packers did last year.  The Vikings are hoping for a miracle that will only last for one more season, when they should be thinking about the future.

I wonder how many weeks it will take the Vikings to regret their decision to sign Favre.

Follow me on Twitter: CorpBarbarian

• Barbaric Book Review: Die Broke by Stephen M. Pollan, Part 3 This is Part 3 of my review of Die Broke.  You can read parts 1 and 2 by clicking on the following links: Die Broke, Part 1 - Quit Today Die Broke, Part 2 - Pay Cash Step 3: Don't Retire Don't retire?  I thought we should be planning for retirement......
• Don't Graduate College During a Recession An article at WallStreetJournal.com delivers some bad news: college graduates from the Class of 2009 face a tough road in their new careers.  Not only will they be entering the toughest labor market in 25 years, but they will suffer lower wages for a decade or more than those who......
• The Time Machine Yesterday was H.G. Wells' birthday.  I've always enjoyed his science fiction stories, especially The Time Machine.  It's tempting to want a do-over, just like when we were kids.  I don't know about you, but there are several decisions that I've made in my life that I'd like to have......

• Retirement: 10 years left, 0 savings - Money Magazine Um, how scary is this? Walter Updegrave from Money Magazine is trying to help these people who have 10 years left until retirement...and no nest egg. First piece of advice? Start saving...like crazy. "If you save $500 a month for the next 10 years and earn an 8 percent annual......
• Planning for Your Retirement The Smart Way As millions of aging baby boomers start contemplating how they are going to survive when they’re no longer working, retirement planning has hit an all time high. Whether you’re just starting out in the workforce, or you’re staring 62 in the face and wondering where the money is going to......
• Retirement Accounts Explained We hear a lot about retirement accounts, but I wanted to spend today's post explaining the different types of accounts. Traditional IRA - Individual Retirement Account Individuals can set up these accounts and invest for their retirement. Individuals put away pre-tax income in these accounts so that when they retire,......