This is Part 2 of my review of Die Broke.  You can read Part 1 by following this link: Barbaric Book Review: Die Broke by Stephen M. Pollan

Step 2: Pay Cash

The authors feel that there are three things that will keep you trapped: an unwillingness to change, and your ATM and credit cards.  These cards represent instant gratification, making it too easy to spend your money.  In order to achieve the goals laid out in the book, you should make spending difficult and uncomfortable.

The argument is that ATM and credit cards take the pain out of spending.  You don’t focus on the amount spent if you’re not counting out the cash.  Online banking and automatic payments distance you even more from bill paying, and you may be charged for the convenience.

The authors offer a few suggestions for Saving and Spending in the Twenty-First Century:

1. Melt Your Plastic - Remove all credit cards from your wallet, and replace them with a charge card for emergencies.  Consolidate your debt on a low interest credit card, and put the card away.
2. Bank with People - Remove the ATM card from your wallet also, and go to the bank once a week for cash.  Withdraw the cash by writing yourself a check.  Don’t spend any more than you’ve withdrawn.
3. Practice Cognitive Spending - Keep track of where every dollar is spent on an index card, then categorize your expenses each week.  This will get you to think about how you spend your money.
4. Buy Your Second Home First - The real estate boom was an anomaly traceable to the baby boom generation driving up the prices for a limited number of homes.  Don’t practice serial home ownership, but save for your dream home.
5. Avoid “Everest” Buying - Don’t buy something “because it’s there.”  Buy things only when you need them, not when you want them.
6. Ignore the New - Don’t buy the latest gadget, but wait forsomething that answers a true need.
7. Repair Before You Replace - Retailers profit more on new things than repairing old things, so focus on repairing what you have.
8. Pay Yourself First - Put away what you can in your 401K, and do it automatically.

My Take:

1. For people that have no self-control, this is the best advice.  However, if you’re responsible, you can use credit cards to your advantage, such as rewards or zero-interest arbitrage, provided you pay off the balance each month.
2. I’m disciplined enough that I don’t abuse my ATM card.  I stick to my weekly budget.  I rarely go to the bank.
3. I track most large expenses, but our walking-around money doesn’t get analyzed.  As long as we stay under our weekly allowance I’m happy.
4. Well, we’re living in our first home, and probably will for the near future.  We bought the home in part for the tax advantages, and have added on to it over time, paying cash for the improvements.  We’ve also paid off our mortgage.
5. I use a cooling-off period to counteract impulse buys.  Can’t argue with that one.
6. Or that one, either.
7. I repair rather than replace if it makes sense.  I’m not upgrading an old computer if I can buy a new one for the same price as the repair.
8. We do this.  The key is to automate it.  Pretend you didn’t get that raise, and put that away, too.

In Part 3 of my review of Die Broke, we’ll examine the third step, called Don’t Retire.

Follow me on Twitter: CorpBarbarian

 Print This Post

• Barbaric Book Review: The Wealthy Barber The Wealthy Barber by David Chilton was first published in 1991.  It's a basic financial guide, told in a narrative style, about three young people who seek financial advice from the town barber.  Yes, you read that correctly, a barber. The story follows a young teacher as he learns, along......
• Pay Off Debt or Save Money? Photo by db*photography A recent Yahoo! Finance article weighed the benefits of paying off debt versus putting your money into savings.  You can read the original article by clicking on the following link: Should You Pay Debt Before Saving? Clearly, there is no one-size-fits-all answer to the question.  The......
• 5 Ways to Grow Your Shrinking Nest Egg mary_thompson Your 401k is looking more like a 201k.  A pension is a relic from your parents' time.  Pretty soon, you may not even have a job to complain about.  Maybe your dreams of early retirement will have to remain only dreams.  SmartMoney recently had an article listing 5......

• 6 Steps to Get Back on the Right Financial Track Millions of Americans have found out this year that they are in dire financial straits and this came as a shock to most. Whether it’s a new variable rate on a mortgage, higher gas prices or just the higher cost of living, many of us are not as financially secure......
• Ixnay on the Asticplay With point-of-sale terminals just about everywhere and one-click ordering, it seems strange not paying for things with plastic. Debit cards (usually doubling as ATM cards) aren't quite as bad as credit cards, but "it's still plastic," as Liz Pulliam Weston writes: Leave your ATM card at home Debit cards don't......
• Saving Money with Your Credit Cards pt 1 When it comes to personal budgeting, we tend to try to think of ways that we can cut corners while cutting down on any frivolous expenses in our lives. What many people are not apparently aware of however is that you can actually make use of credit cards to help......